Multiscale Modeling and Viral Pandemics
To join this working group please complete this form
To signup for subgroups please complete this form
** A recent NIH Research Funding Announcement that may be of interest **
A Multi-omics Approach to Immune Responses in HIV Vaccination and Intervention (P01 Clinical Trial Not Allowed)
** A recent publication from a group member **
Drug Development Digital Twins for Drug Discovery, Testing and Repurposing:
A Schema for Requirements and Development.
Gary An and Chase Cockrell.
PERSPECTIVE article, Front. Syst. Biol., 20 June 2022
For the June 23 at 3:00 PM Eastern time teleconference, please join at
The schedule for this week consists of one presentation:
Viral Pandemics Working Group FUTURE TALKS
Furthermore, if you have suggestions for potential speakers please fill out a Suggested Invitees Google Form. We will do our very best to schedule your potential seminar or to invite speakers according to your suggestions as soon as possible.
For details of the past and future teleconferences, including YouTube videos and slides,
You can access the entire set of Viral Pandemic WG seminars at our YouTube Playlist:
IMAG's COVID-19 modeling and data resources page is here.
Recent media about group members or the group's activities:
- Son's health issues fuel UNL researcher's interest in building virtual immune system, Omaha World-Herald, Feb 27, 2022. Newspaper article about Tomáš Helikar's work on digital twins of the immune system, with additional commentary from James Glazier and Reinhard Laubenbacher.
- Medical Digital Twins: a New Frontier, ACM News Feb 24, 2022. ACM news article about Reinhard Laubenbacher's recent paper.
Recent Publications from group members:
- Laubenbacher R, Niarakis A, Helikar T, An G, Shapiro B, Malik-Sheriff RS, Sego TJ, Knapp A, Macklin P, Glazier JA. Building digital twins of the human immune system: toward a roadmap NPJ Digit Med. 2022 May 20;5(1):64. doi: 10.1038/s41746-022-00610-z. PMID: 35595830; PMCID: PMC9122990.
- JM Sasso, BJB Ambrose, R Tenchov, RS Datta, MT Basel, RK DeLong, QA Zhou. The Progress and Promise of RNA Medicine─An Arsenal of Targeted Treatments. J Med Chem. 2022 May 9. doi: 10.1021/acs.jmedchem.2c00024. Epub ahead of print. PMID: 35533054.
- Dale Larie, Gary An, Robert Chase Cockrell. Preparing for the next COVID: Deep Reinforcement Learning trained Artificial Intelligence discovery of multi-modal immunomodulatory control of systemic inflammation in the absence of effective anti-microbials. http://dx.doi.org/10.1101/2022.02.17.480940
- Gary An. Specialty Grand Challenge: What it will take to cross the Valley of Death: Translational Systems Biology, “True” Precision Medicine, Medical Digital Twins, Artificial Intelligence and In Silico Clinical trials. https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fsysb.2022.901159/full
- Karr J, Malik-Sheriff RS, Osborne J, Gonzalez-Parra G, Forgoston E, Bowness R, Liu Y, Thompson R, Garira W, Barhak J, Rice J, Torres M, Dobrovolny HM, Tang T, Waites W, Glazier JA, Faeder JR and Kulesza A (2022) Model Integration in Computational Biology: The Role of Reproducibility, Credibility and Utility. Front. Syst. Biol. 2:822606. doi: 10.3389/fsysb.2022.822606 https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fsysb.2022.822606/full
- Larie D, An G, Cockrell RC. "Preparing for the next COVID: Deep Reinforcement Learning trained Artificial Intelligence discovery of multi-modal immunomodulatory control of systemic inflammation in the absence of effective anti-microbials." Preprint, Feb. 18, 2022. https://www.biorxiv.org/content/10.1101/2022.02.17.480940v1.
- Waites W, Cavaliere M, Danos V, Datta R, Eggo RM, Hallett TB, Manheim D, Panovska-Griffiths J, Russell TW, Zarnitsyna VI. "Compositional modelling of immune response and virus transmission dynamics." https://arxiv.org/abs/2111.02510.
- Sego TJ, Mochan ED, Ermentrout GB, Glazier JA. "A multiscale multicellular spatiotemporal model of local influenza infection and immune response." J Theor Biol. 2021 Sep 27;532:110918. doi: 10.1016/j.jtbi.2021.110918. Epub ahead of print. PMID: 34592264; PMCID: PMC8478073.
- Sego TJ, Aponte-Serrano JO, Gianlupi JF, Glazier JA. "Generation of multicellular spatiotemporal models of population dynamics from ordinary differential equations, with applications in viral infection". BMC Biol. 2021 Sep 8;19(1):196. doi: 10.1186/s12915-021-01115-z. PMID: 34496857.
- Veronika I Zarnitsyna, Juliano Ferrari Gianlupi, Amit Hagar, TJ Sego, James A Glazier. "Advancing therapies for viral infections using mechanistic computational models of the dynamic interplay between the virus and host immune response." Current Opinion in Virology, 50, October 2021, Pages 103-109.
- Cockrell, C.; An, G. "Comparative Computational Modeling of the Bat and Human Immune Response to Viral Infection with the Comparative BiologyImmune Agent Based Model." Viruses 2021, 13, 1620. https://doi.org/10.3390/v13081620.
- Masison, J., J. Beezley, Y. Mei, H. a. L. Ribeiro, A. C. Knapp, L. Sordo Vieira, B. Adhikari, Y. Scindia, M. Grauer, B. Helba,W. Schroeder, B. Mehrad, R. Laubenbacher. “A Modular Computational Framework for Medical Digital Twins.” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 118, no. 20 (May 18, 2021). https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.2024287118.
- Sarah M Bartsch, Patrick T Wedlock, Kelly J O’Shea, Sarah N Cox, Ulrich Strych, Jennifer B Nuzzo, Marie C Ferguson, Maria Elena Bottazzi, Sheryl S Siegmund, Peter J Hotez, Bruce Y Lee, Lives and Costs Saved by Expanding and Expediting Coronavirus Disease 2019 Vaccination, The Journal of Infectious Diseases, Volume 224, Issue 6, 15 September 2021, Pages 938–948, https://academic.oup.com/jid/article/224/6/938/6267841 .
- Laubenbacher R, Sluka JP, Glazier JA. Using digital twins in viral infection. Science. 2021 Mar 12;371(6534):1105-1106. doi: 10.1126/science.abf3370.
- Getz M, Wang Y, An G, Asthana M, Becker A, Cockrell C, Collier N, Craig M, Davis CL, Faeder JR, Versypt ANF, Mapder T, Gianlupi JF, Glazier JA, Hamis S, Heiland R, Hillen T, Hou D, Islam MA, Jenner AL, Kurtoglu F, Larkin CI, Liu B, Macfarlane F, Maygrundter P, Morel PA, Narayanan A, Ozik J, Pienaar E, Rangamani P, Saglam AS, Shoemaker JE, Smith AM, Weaver JJA, Macklin P. Iterative community-driven development of a SARS-CoV-2 tissue simulator. bioRxiv [Preprint]. 2021 Apr 29:2020.04.02.019075. doi: 10.1101/2020.04.02.019075. PMID: 32511322; PMCID: PMC7239052.
James A. Glazier, PhD, Indiana University, JAGlazier@gmail.com
Tomas Helikar, PhD, University of Nebraska-Lincoln, firstname.lastname@example.org
Rationale: The ongoing COVID-19 pandemic has provided a striking example of the real-world importance of mathematical and computational modeling. Epidemiological simulations have become key technologies for optimizing responses by clinicians and policy makers around the world. Because epidemiological models had already been developed and validated for other infectious diseases before the appearance of SARS-CoV-2, these models were available for rapid repurposing when the COVID-19 crisis started. As a result, sophisticated epidemiological models of COVID-19 are informing healthcare professionals and public leaders as they decide on social restrictions or resource allocation.
However, once a patient is infected with SARS-CoV-2 (or another virus), current modeling technology is not sufficiently advanced to be of much help in assessing risk or guiding treatment. The spread of infection within the body and the immune response to respiratory and other viral pathogens is still poorly understood. The factors determining the beneficial (viral clearance) and harmful (cytokine storm) effects of immune response to COVID-19 are poorly understood. COVID-19 is also a very complex disease, with pathologies developing in organs beyond the sites of primary infection, and thus requiring understanding of the responses of multiple organ systems (especially the vasculature and blood) and their interactions. As the disease progresses over the course of weeks and months, coinfection between respiratory viruses is likely and its significance poorly understood. Therapies under consideration are also complex, with possible combination therapies combining phased dosages of novel and existing antivirals, pro-and anti-inflammatory drugs and antibodies. Such therapies will need to be personalized, and their combinatorial complexity makes evaluation with clinical studies which do not employ modeling for prioritization prohibitively time consuming and costly. The complex pattern of comorbidities to COVID-19 is suggestive but their significance is still unclear. Minority populations are at much greater risk both of being infected with SARS-CoV-2 and of dying from COVID-19, once infected. It is an urgent matter of health equity to understand and remediate these vulnerabilities. While the former (susceptibility) are primarily the subject of epidemiological models, the latter (death rates) are appropriate topics for the models the Working Group will consider. The COVID-19 epidemic has also brought modeling of infections into popular consciousness, education at all levels and policy making to an unprecedented degree. The development of models of human infection and response provide great opportunities for education and dissemination.
We currently lack platform tools for the evaluation of viral infections, their responses, and treatment opportunities like the epidemiology models that were available to customize for COVID-19. With partial exceptions for influenza and HIV/AIDS, few computational models attempt to collectively understand and harness the key drivers of infection progression for prognosis and optimal design of interventions. Even the most sophisticated current models do not usually include the details of immune response and inter-organ interactions that seem critical to COVID-19 and will be essential if the models are to serve as a platform for response to future viruses. Another obstacle to using modeling as a guide to treatment is the relative lack of ability to personalize such models using readily available data, such as lung CT scans, immune profiles from repeated blood draws, or comorbidities and other information from patient health records. This personalization of predefined and calibrated models is key, as COVID-19 has shown with its unpredictability of patient response. Added challenges are a better understanding of host-pathogen interactions, and the connection between the population and patient-level scales. These and other challenges make clear that the determination of an effective response to viral pandemics is a multiscale many-faceted problem whose solution has to rely on multiscale mathematical and computational models. The IMAG community is ideally positioned to lead an initiative to develop and help execute a strategy for developing and applying this technology.
Focus and structure of the working group: The community of modelers developing epidemiological and population-scale models is already extensive and well-integrated, in part due to the NIGMS MIDAS program. Within-host modeling of viral pathogens is much more limited. Therefore, the working group will initially focus on within-host scales, in particular the complex interactions between viral infection, host physiology, and the immune system. A main long-term deliverable of the working group will be an overall strategy for a coordinated multi-scale modeling effort which becomes a customizable translational technological platform for rapidly creating improved personalized prognoses and therapies in response to emerging viral pandemics. It will also include a plan on how to mobilize and coordinate the modeling community to support this effort.
The working group will be organized as follows:
A steering group, consisting of approximately 20 scientists, including modelers, data scientists, experimental and clinical domain experts, such as immunologists and virologists and representatives of affected communities and potential tool users, with special emphasis on the effects of the disease on disproportionately affected populations.
The steering group and subgroups will contain scientists from academia, the private sector, and government, also relying heavily on the members of the IMAG working groups. The working group will be widely advertised, and membership is open to all scientists. In addition, the co-leads will proactively invite scientists to join the steering group.
Member List is available here.
Tissue Damage and Recovery
Viral Transport and Modes of Entry
Viral Replication and Release
Modeling Decontamination of Surfaces/Materials
Machine Learning for Health Monitoring
Heart and Vasculature
Kidney and Liver
Clinical and Experimental Data for Model Construction and Validation
AI-based Data Processing, Heterogeneous Data Fusion
Infection in Experimental Models
Infection in zoonotic reservoir animals and Interspecies transmission
Coinfection and/or Other Pathogens (Virus-Virus, Bacterial, Eukaryotic)
Emerging and Reemerging Diseases
Lung, Pulmonary Circulation and Aerosol Transport
Knowledge Acquisition and Modeling
Communication to Funding Agencies
Initial list of deliverables and goals:
- Advertise for and recruit members as widely as possible.
- Establishment of the steering group and subgroups with all needed areas of expertise, as well as an effective communication structure, including regular meetings and information sharing resources
- A report that includes a map of the main processes to be modeled, available models, available data, and main laboratories around the world doing related research
- List of most important models, data, techniques that are still missing
- Plan of how to integrate existing as well as future models
- Plan for approaches to validation and uncertainty quantification when model components are developed simultaneously and independently
- Article about the initiative for a medical audience, published in NEJM, JAMA, or similar journal
- Article about the initiative for a modeling audience, published in Nature Digital Medicine, or similar journal
- Refinement of the six-month deliverables
- Virtual one-day workshop on the report and next steps
- Comprehensive strategic plan for the development of a “digital twin” for therapeutics for an individual patient suffering from a viral infection
- Plan for training of computational scientists who want to contribute to the initiative
- Plan for use of models in training of STEM students and the general population
- First steps toward implementation of this plan, including the identification of challenges and required resources
- Well-established organization of an international integrated research community in modeling of viral pandemics across scales
Slack Channel: msm-working-group.slack.com
YouTube Channel: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCuDFvhgFziRRDcpRnT3vlrw, however, the most compete list of seminars (along with slides) is our seminars page at https://www.imagwiki.nibib.nih.gov/content/msm-viral-pandemics-meetings.
You can also access the entire set of Viral Pandemic WG seminars at our YouTube Playlist:
(click the "Subscribe" button if you would like to be notified when new videos are posted)
From members of Multiscale Modeling and Viral Pandemics Working Group, prior to group formation:
- Sego TJ, Aponte-Serrano JO, Ferrari Gianlupi J, Heaps SR, Breithaupt K, Brusch L, Osborne JM, Quardokus EM, Plemper RK, Glazier JA. A modular framework for multiscale, multicellular, spatiotemporal modeling of acute primary viral infection and immune response in epithelial tissues and its application to drug therapy timing and effectiveness, bioRxiv 2020.04.27.064139; doi: https://doi.org/10.1101/2020.04.27.064139.
- Getz M, Wang Y, An G, Becker A, Cockrell C, Collier N, Craig M, Davis CL, Faeder J, Ford Versypt AN, Ferrari Gianlupi J, Glazier JA, Hamis S, Heiland R, Hillen T, Hou D, Aminul Islam M, Jenner A, Kurtoglu F, Liu B, Macfarlane F, Maygrundter P, Morel PA, Narayanan A, Ozik J, Pienaar E, Rangamani P, Shoemaker JE, Smith AM, Macklin P. Rapid community-driven development of a SARS-CoV-2 tissue simulator, bioRxiv 2020.04.02.019075; doi: https://doi.org/10.1101/2020.04.02.019075.
- de Almeida RMC, Thomas GL, Glazier JA, Transcriptogram analysis reveals relationship between viral titer and gene sets responses during Corona-virus infection, bioRxiv 2020.06.16.155267; doi: https://doi.org/10.1101/2020.06.16.155267.
The initial teleconference was Thursday October 22, 2020 at 3PM US Eastern Time. The meeting had 72 attendees. The recording of the first meeting via Zoom is available at:
Meetings and Teleconferences
We are holding zoom meetings for the entire working group every Thursday afternoon at 3PM Eastern US time. The complete schedule of past and future meetings is here.
We have a page of handy links for activities related to the working group here.
This page, our top level page for the Viral Pandemics WG has the tiny URL https://tinyurl.com/hkr97vfe .
Our initial charge to the working groups is outlined below:
Based on the proposal submitted to the IMAG/MSM Steering Committee, the objectives for the working group as a whole and each of the subgroups are as follows:
Objectives for subgroups for the first 9 months:
Develop a plan to achieve the objectives listed below. (Target delivery December 31, 2020)
Identify people working in this area and include a paragraph on their work. (Target delivery February 28, 2021)
Assemble a directory of researchers with bibliography
Identify other subgroups that you should coordinate with
Prepare a white paper, approx. 5pp in length, excluding references that does the following: (Target delivery May 31, 2021)
Describe the focus of the subgroup, the major open problems to address, and the role modeling can play
Describe what models and data are available, and the extent of our biological knowledge, available experimental systems, etc.
Describe what is needed to address these problems that does not exist yet: models, data, experimental approaches, etc.
Outline any action items that could get us to solutions to these problems.
These white papers can form the basis of a collective publication on the topic of multiscale modeling and viral pandemics.
Catalyze research projects through presentations, exchange of ideas, search for strategic opportunities. (Target delivery August 30, 2021)
Note: The list below only includes individuals that are members of both the working group and members of IMAG/MSM. For a complete list of all members of the working group please see the Member List is here.